As Much As You Love Him Your Dog Is Not Your Child

dog

by Aja Dorsey Jackson

Before I get rocks thrown at me from animal lovers around the world, let me preface this by saying I love dogs. The puppy that I got in the third grade didn’t die until I turned 21 and losing him really did feel like losing a member of the family. I don’t own a dog now only because we own two cats and have a baby in diapers and I refuse to clean up after anything else until one of those scenarios changes.

That being said, nothing amuses me more than to hear someone talking about their kids and to hear another person chime in with “I know because my dogs…”

Pets are like children in some ways. They make messes and don’t clean up after themselves. They’re active. They like lots of attention. They make me cuss at least once a day (Don’t judge me. I’m working on it). But the similarities are few and the differences are what makes having pets absolutely nothing like raising children.

Outside of extreme cases where people intentionally abuse or neglect animals, or train them to be especially vicious, dogs grow up to be dogs. Let your dog run around aimlessly in the backyard for hours or let him sit on the couch while you watch TV. Walk him, or hire a dogwalker. Feed him Science Diet or Kibbles and Bits, dress him up or not, put him in the kennel while you go on vacation, he’s still going to love you when you get home, and when he grows up he’s still going to be a dog. I know that as a nation we have become particularly obsessed with our pets, but if you set your obsession aside, your dog will probably grow up to be the same dog he was going to be anyway.

On the other hand, you raise children with the knowledge that you need to give them all of the building blocks to someday be able to go out on their own and become productive members of society. To do this effectively requires a constant investment in them, monitoring of their activities and effort in passing on the morals and values that you want them to carry for a lifetime.  You raise your children to be ready to leave you while you’re probably raising your dog to be with you for the rest of his life.

Think twice before comparing your dog to someone’s child. If you’re having trouble telling the difference here is a tip: If it brings you happiness, joy, and maybe even your slippers, it’s probably a dog. If it brings you happiness, joy, gray hair, and a touch of insanity, it’s probably a child.

(Please don’t email me with stories about your very smart police dog or the dog that you taught to flush the toilet. I know they are special, but I’m just sayin’….)

Aja Dorsey Jackson is a freelance writer and marketing consultant in Baltimore, Maryland. Visit her blog, The Write Resource at http://ajadorseyjackson.com/BLOG.html


About the author

Lamar and Ronnie Tyler are the creators of the award-winning blog BlackandMarriedWithKids.com . They also are behind the Amazon.com bestselling DVDs Happily Ever After: A Positive Image of Black Marriage, You Saved Me and Men Ain’t Boys that explores manhood in the African American community. The Tylers are also the proud parents of four children.



Related Posts with Thumbnails

 
Add a comment

Comments (22)

  1. Political Pete Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Lamar, the blog got a shout out via steve Harvey morning show this morning
  2. Mari Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Sorry, our dogs are our "babies." Of course they are not children, but they have sparked some really good discussions with me and hubby about division of care at home, diet, training style, vet visits, education, etc. They definitely don't run around the backyard alone all day, not good for socialization. They eat organic food (allergies) and they go to doggy daycare. I think people without children are just trying to participate in the discussion and share a frame of reference when they bring up their dogs in kid conversations. It's just being polite, sociable and trying to make conversation. We all know dogs are not kids! The other side of being sociable is not constantly steering conversations to your kids when around people who don't have them. If you don't want us to try to relate with our (puppy, neice, cousin, students), then keep the conversation of topics that are relevant and interesting to the whole group.
  3. African American Mom Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Ooooo, you might get some real flack for this one. I am not a dog lover but I have realized over the years that people do not PLAY about their dogs. Good Luck! .-= African American Mom´s last blog ..I am late on the Crazy Weatherman--Jim Kosek =-.
  4. Aja Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Thanks AA Mom. I have been cursed out often enough on here. I am prepared. LOL.
  5. MrsT Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Organic dog food and doggy daycare. Wow.
  6. MTM Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Thank you! I can't handle it. I am on a neighborhood listserv, and literally 3/4 of the posts are about animals. People seem to care more about animals than about other people, and it drives me crazy. And they seem to forget that dogs are tuned to survive in the wild. My preschooler? Notsomuch. While I can't feel Mari on her attachment to her dogs, (and trust, MrsT, it gets much, much more involved -- doggy spas and health insurance come to mind) I do feel her point about making an effort not to alienate childless people in your conversations.
  7. Shayla Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Very interesting take on comparing dogs and children!! I think that the term "man or womans best friend" is the best way to describe the relationship between the a person and their dog. If I sit here an think about it long enough, I can see that those are some serious differences. While I am a dog lover, I do not have one, and I have often told my husband can I have a dog since we do not have any kids yet. He has always said no since he is not a dog lover and that he would prefer the kid. Little does he know that this is where the dog and the child are very similar (cleaning up after them and keeping them entertained). The main reason why I would sometimes prefer the dog first, because the older they get the more accustom they become in being a little more self sufficient (they let you know when they need to be let out to do their business) and they will never talk back. Now they may give you an attitude every now and then, but at least you will never hear the dog tell you what they are not going to do which of course would result in a serious beat down!! Great Article as always Aja!!!!
  8. Aja Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Oh I completely agree with that MTM. I think that I am probably equally annoyed when I hear people talking about children non-stop and I have children! But I also think that's its ok to acknowledge sometimes that we are in different places and not have to compare apples to oranges. I used to work with a group of dog lovers that literally talked about their dogs all day. One day I came into work and was telling someone that I was really worried because my daughter had pneumonia at the time and had one of my coworkers say I understand how that is because my dog....I'm sorry, I just feel like your dog having the sniffles and my daughter having pneumonia aren't the same. I never chimed into the dog conversation and talked about my fish, why should this be any different?
  9. Tara @ The Young Mommy Life Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    I do not like dogs. Period. It reminds me of slavery. Breeding, going to buy it, separating it from the mother, you're now it's "Master," etc. Makes me shiver. (Side note: I know I have issues.) I understand dogs are companions and can become part of the family, but if it came down to it, who is going to take priority - your kids or the dog? The kids. Point blank. End of story. (For those of you who even had to think about it, I'm praying for you. Hard.) For those who only have dogs and no kids, I am a little more lenient. I don't really care if they pay for doggy daycare or have them drinking Evian, but I don't like it when they feel they already have parenting experience because they've had Fido for a number of years. Not the same thing at all. (Now watch ME get prepared to get cussed out. Aja, I think I have the slight edge on "Most Cuss-outs" in BMWK history. You are a very close second and might eclipse me with this post. LOL) .-= Tara @ The Young Mommy Life´s last blog ..making changes =-.
  10. Aja Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    @ Tara interesting you brought up the priority issue because I got FLAMED on a parenting board for suggesting to a pregnant woman with a very aggressive dog that posed a potential danger to her baby that she give her dog away. I was told that suggesting that was like saying she should choose between her children. So please lift her and her dog/baby and real baby up in prayer. ( I think you might still continue to hold the cuss-out title with posts like the Wifey one-LoL)
  11. Harriet Wednesday - 17 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    I'm just appalled that we are sitting here comparing how many times we have been cursed out on this site. I think we're sending the wrong impression. (you can cut that sarcasm and eat it, can't you? ROFL) On a more serious note, although I have not been cursed out (except on one article a while ago...dang, I need to play catch up...look for controversy and mayhem from me in the near future), I agree. Dogs are dogs. Children are children. I never had a pet growing up (turtles don't count...it ran away, and I didn't catch it...a TURTLE), so I can't relate to the attachment too well. My mom got a dog after I'd left home. We have a love/hate relationship, but I know we'd all be heartbroken if anything happened to him. But he's a dachsund, not a daughter. I just don't think I can fully relate to the attachment. That's just me.
  12. VEe! Thursday - 18 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Hmm . . . I'm smiling, and LAUGHING. I know there are some dogs that receive better healthcare than some children not to mention food. .-= VEe!´s last blog ..Old worth =-.
  13. {Ms. P} Thursday - 18 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    @Mari: Get outta my head... @MTM: That might be b/c animals are more loyal than a human can ever imagine. As a dog-lover, I'm not totally offended by your article. I guess b/c I've heard it all the time. In 2007, my pitbull ("Gucci") was euthanized by Animal Control. It was a pain worse than I could ever imagine. In fact, I get misty-eyed whenever I think about it. Aside from her senseless death, the response that I received from people regarding my grief hurt just as much. I won't go into detail about my response, but when you're going thru the death (or illness) of a pet, the LAST thing you wanna hear is "its JUST a dog". Gucci was more than JUST a dog to me. To me, that's just as insensitive as "it was JUST your grandmother". Regardless of the relation, its something that I care about. (and yes, I know that no one is gonna care as much about MY dog as I do, but still...you don't have to be an ass about it.) Insensitive is insensitive. Don't dismiss me. Now, I never dressed Gucci up in clothes or anything like that, but...she was very well-fed (what dog YOU know has dined on hour-old steak from Chophouse & prefers ice cubes in her water? LOL). I don't have children, but I am an aunt & Godmother. @VeE!: I treated my dog better than some people treat their children. Pretty sad, huh? :-( .-= {Ms. P}´s last blog ..Happy Valentine's Day! =-.
  14. Celie Friday - 19 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Um.....I think most childfree by choice pet parents like myself know that our dogs are nothing like kids. They are so much better. And that's exactly why we love them! :) .-= Celie´s last blog ..I Don't Call Men Dogs Because It's Unfair to Dogs! =-.
  15. The Gentleman Friday - 19 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    @ Aja .. Dont worry Im sure I will get cussed out about this BUT it is what it is and Im a man so let me take some of that burden off your shoulders .. Okay Okay Okay .. I can't take it anymore .. BUT I will play devil's advocate anyway since this is a blog spot and we are here to speak our mind and share our thoughts .. I LOVE PETS ... BUT a pet is just what it says it is a PET. We go to PET stores to get PETS not to get stand-in children and thats a fact. IF anyone on here who is an avid PET (Dogs in this case) lover PLEASE share with me what you said when you picked up your Dog (PET) from the PET store. Did you say ooooooo that looks like the perfect Dog for me that I can spoil as if it needed me to do that for it. Dogs will always be Dogs and they are wild animals that were domesticated back in the days kind of like how slavery was started. Somewhere along the way I do believe that society went wrong when people put more value in their pets than in another human beings life or happiness regardless if they are living in your house or not. For those adamant PET owners who do go above and beyond the call of duty to make sure that their dogs have toe nail polish and go to spas .. Have you ever thought that maybe their is a homeless person in a shelter who might be better well served by being treated to a spa visit OR an elderly person sitting in a home who just wants a reason to smile and that extra time effort and energy to make sure that your PET has silk satin sheets on the bed that you let it sleep in could be used to stop by and say HELLO? I'm just saying that if we (as a former PET owner of 2 dogs) can value our animals, which is what they are regardless how much you try and convince yourself otherwise, why not put that same amount of effort, energy, and/or money into helping to make our community better for our youth???? NOW LET THE 4 Letter Words of Love begin .. LOL ..
  16. Aja Friday - 19 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Gentleman-Just remember that you said it not me! :)
  17. Lamar Friday - 19 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    uh-oh.... Let's get ready to rumbleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee LOL
  18. The Gentleman Friday - 19 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    Aja its all good Ive got strong shoulders PLUS I have owned 2 dogs in my life so Im not speaking without knowledge. LOL One of my coworkers got frustrated and irritated with me one time because she had a Rottweiler whom she painted its toe nails and used to let it sleep in her bead and she would go sleep on the couch or another room and I told her that I thought it was crazy because Rottweilers first and foremost are not inside dogs as are a lot of other breeds of Dogs which people domesticate and as I shared with her, in my opinion she castrated her dog and it would never be the same. The thing that concerns me the most is that people who are avid dog owners and doing all of this extra stuff for their PET refuse to take responsibility in taking one of GOD's creatures and changing them from being what GOD meant for them to be. Rottweilers originated in Germany as herding dogs .. they are outside animals .. they do not need a bed to sleep in their nails done or a spa .. Thats just one example BUT as I mentioned before I have owned 2 dogs and been a PET lover for years so there are soo many stories that I could share BUT I spose at the end of the day a person is going to do what a person is going to do regardless if its right or wrong. Im just saying make sure that your spoiled PET stays away from mines because mines will know that its a dog and it will act accordingly. = )
  19. Funkidivagirl Monday - 22 / 02 / 2010 Reply
    As always, the line is drawn between "dog people" and "non-dog people". I am a dog person. I am also a mother. Of course my dog is not my child and there is no question of my priority or love or concern about who comes first! But my daughter does refer to my puppy as my "third baby", so I guess that tells you something. He has the best organic dog food, the best doctor and yes he does go to doggy daycare once a week just for fun. I toured 4 daycares/boarding places before deciding on the current one. He is a "being" that I am nurturing and caring for and as his owner/surrogate mother and a responsible dog owner I feel obliged to give him the best care that I can. My husband is not a dog person and does not treat the puppy like I do....to him he is "just a dog" and really, a pain. .-= Funkidivagirl´s last blog ..Disney World’s Social Media Moms Celebration 2010 =-.
  20. Biculturalwifenmom Saturday - 27 / 03 / 2010 Reply
    **disclaimer: I know this may get me e-cussed out, but at least I'm honest! I'm not really irritated by people loving their dogs to the maximum and doing all kinds of special things for them and treating them like gold. People have their reasons, I know people who can't have kids but have so much love and affection to give and a pet is the easiest way to let it out (though I agree with Gentleman in that there are other ways to let it out as well, on humans, but to each his/her own). Don't misunderstand, I'm not saying people just get dogs to replace kids either. Other people just grew up with animals and feel their life is incomplete without them. Some just met an animal they love and live happily ever after. The only thing that irritates me is when people put greater value on animal lives than other human lives. Some of the examples that upset me most: people chartering buses to get dogs out of New Orleans after hurricane Katrina while thousands of people sat in the Superdome with no way out. The woman in San Francisco who locked her 6 year old son in the basement and let her two pitbulls roam the house, then when her son came out of the basement and the dogs killed him, she defended the dogs and said " I told him (the son) to stay in the basement". The woman whose chimp ripped her friend''s face and hands off who was more sad about losing her chimp. People who let their vicious pets run around without a leash knowing that they regularly terrorize people in their neighborhoods. People who want Michael Vick's life to be over but don't say anything about urban violence, or try to help protect kids from child predators, or are against universal health care for that matter (to clarify, I'm not defending Michael Vick's actions at all, choking and drowning anything is just sick). People who feed and care for their animals significantly better than they do their kids or their aging parents. I can remember couple of years ago in the metro area where I lived there were about 4 cases of violent dogs murdering people in a six week period. One lady had to throw her weeks- old infant in a trash can to save it from an attack from the neighbors dog--in her own garage. Oh, and lastly, people who buy dogs that are significantly bigger and stronger than they are and then can't physically control them. No matter how sweet you claim your dog is, or that it is for that matter, that scares the hell out of people, especially people with young kids. And yes, I'm prepared to get flamed. Now please believe that I know these are extreme cases and that the overwhelming majority of people have a healthy love for their pets as well as a healthy love for human kind, and many many many many many people in my life have dogs and they love them to death and I love them too. And I also have a kid and have had pets and I love them both, but please please please if it comes down to it, put humans first.
  21. lana Monday - 24 / 05 / 2010 Reply
    I am a child free dog lover...my friends send out holiday cards of beautiful children while hubby and I send out cards of our dog with reindeer antlers.
  22. ann Monday - 24 / 05 / 2010 Reply
    Aja, I can't have kids so I have 2 dogs. I have nieces & nephews that I love and would lay my life down for. But they aren't "mine." I dont get to tuck them into bed every night or take care of them when they are sick. I love to be able to come home to "my" family. No, they are not children, but as I will never know the joy of having children, I want to share my love with animals that had nowhere else to go (they are both shelter dogs) I agree with Mari. I may not always want hear about your kids, like you may not always want to hear about my dogs, but we are all friends, so let's support each other and share the love we all have to give to our famlies, no matter what they look like.

Add a comment

advert