Should I Tell My Friend She’s Being a Bad Mother?

I am blessed to have several wonderful women in my life – some are mothers, and others are not. I can safely say that most of them have parenting styles that are similar to mine. Just recently, I made the acquaintance of a nice woman with whom I have lots in common. We are both from the South, both married with kids that are close to the same ages, and we share the same sense of humor.

We’ve done a few shopping trips, with most of our interactions being “Girls’ Night Out” without the kids.  However recently, I was able to witness her parenting style up close and personal; and boy was I in for a shock! As I struggle with the judgement of how anyone handles their own children, I couldn’t help but take notice, especially when there’s a possibility of a play date in our future… at her house…when I’m not around.

The first thing I noticed was that she dropped several “F” bombs, not only around her children, but when talking to her children. (Ummm No!) I noticed that she screamed at them for simply just “being kids”. (You have to let kids be kids.) I also noticed that she talked badly about her husband in front of her children. (Again, just no!) These are things that I completely disagree with.

So here is the dilemma. She and I have really started to develop a great friendship.  But after I saw her handle her kids up close and personal, I’m now beginning to question it.

Now what???

Do I just say, “Girl, you are so wrong for talking to your kids like that.” Or, “You shouldn’t talk about your husband like that in front of the kids.”

No, I don’t think so. Instead, I’m gonna try to do what the Williams Brothers say and “sweep around my own front door, before I try to sweep around hers”.

I’m thinking more along the lines of trying to be an example instead of a judgmental female/mom. I may not be the bomb-dropping, profanity popping mom.  But I am definitely a “yeller”. That’s something that I need to work on. For accountability, I have even told my kids to remind me when I’m yelling at them.  Because sometimes I’m yelling and I don’t even know it.

For now, I am okay with some supervised play dates.  I know while I’m around and interacting with my kids, I may be able to help her see that she can work on a few things. I once read a quote that said: “Lower your voice and strengthen your argument.” When I read it, it resonated with me and how I deal with my kids and even my husband. (Although, that quote flies right out the window when my house looks like a tornado or when everyone in the house just can’t seem to get it together.)

I appreciate my new friend for showing me that none of us moms are perfect and for making me stop and shine the light on my own imperfections and work on them accordingly.

BMWK – How would you handle this situation? Would you say something to your friend? Would you stop being friends with her?  

 

 


About the author

Sheree is a wife and WAHM of three who passionately blogs about marriage, family, health tips and more as Smart & Sassy Mom. Sheree is committed to helping blended families and keeping marriages strong, healthy, fun and SPICY!


Get Marriage Articles Delivered To Your Inbox Daily!

 
 
Add a comment

Comments (12)

  1. Tiya Cunningham-Sumter Tuesday - 16 / 10 / 2012 Reply
    Sheree, Great topic. I too have a friend like this and I agree with you. It is best to lead by example. We can't tell anyone how to parent. For the most part we are doing what we think is best. But it sounds like she can learn from you.
  2. Niambi Tuesday - 16 / 10 / 2012 Reply
    I think it's important to be honest with her. But it has to be said in a way that is respectable so that she can receive it. I wouldn't start off with "girl you a bad mother and wife". I woud instead maybe ask if we could go out to lunch somewhere and maybe say "I have some things that i wanted to share with you that are on my heart..." Perhaps you will find that she grew up a certain way and that's why she speaks the way she does or maybe she never knew what a "good marriage" actually looks like. Alot of times people repeat what they learned from their parents so if they were exposed to an emotionally and/or physically abusive enviornment growing up then their is a higher likelyhood that they would pass this on because its all that she knows. I would also pray first and ask the Lord to lead me on this issue. He may touch her heart and she ready to receive what you are saying when you do talk. Continue to pray for her as a woman of God and wife that God would help her, her marriage and her children. A true friend would tell her the truth, but make sure you speak the truth in love.
  3. Natalie Tuesday - 16 / 10 / 2012 Reply
    When I first read the title of this piece I thought that this woman was being neglectful and abusive. As I read the article and realized that this lady was just different from the author, I put myself in the place of her "friend", and I can tell you that if someone I didn't know that well even began to point out ways in which I was a "bad" wife and mother because I didn't conduct myself as she does it would not set well, the person conducting the lecture would be told just that, and that would be the end of that friendship with no hesitation. Considering how the author feels about how this lady parents and carries out her duties as a wife, I am surprised that she considers the woman a friend in the first place. Maybe the author could just limit her interaction with this lady to Girls' Night Out, and do playdates and couples-oriented activities with church members. Since the author doesn't agree with some of her friend's actions regarding to her parenting style or how she speaks about her husband in front of her kids, she should probably avoid those situations and settings when she socializes with her.
  4. OlayiM'Ade Tuesday - 16 / 10 / 2012 Reply
    The truth may hurt but it will save her from good people finding it difficult to associate with her or her family. She may have to diassociate herself from some colleagues who promote prafanity. Also, you help the children who by now could be ashamed their parent uses profanity. More so, you help make the world a safer and curse-free zone; because surely, there is power in the tongue! What you say is what becomes. Better still, make a list of replacement vocabulary and share them with her; that will make her know you have her best interest at heart.
  5. vivian mcrae Wednesday - 17 / 10 / 2012 Reply
    Friends can say anything about anything. Sista girl need a real friend right now. The reason she do what she do is because she is hurt by what she want her relationship to be and it not being. BE KIND, BUT TELL HER IN A SUGGESTED WAY, advise counseling or refer her to a good church.
  6. vivian mcrae Wednesday - 17 / 10 / 2012 Reply
    A strong, real Christian base church will be all sista girl need. The Bible hold the answer to all her problems. GIVING HERSELF TO GOD COMPLETELY, and all her problems will be GONE. Girlfriend is not HAPPY. Husband probably don't care, encourage her to seek help for the CHILDREN sake. Your prayers can WORK WONDER. DON'T JUST SIT AND DO NOTHING. BE THE FRIEND YOU MENTIONED YOU ARE.
  7. Betsey Wednesday - 17 / 10 / 2012 Reply
    People learn best by example.
  8. Marianne Saturday - 03 / 11 / 2012 Reply
    Very Impressive article. Initially, I though it would be about a mom who you witnessed abuse her child. I really appreciate your take on this situation. If I were your friend, I would value our friendship because you choose to educate me via example instead of attacking me by being judgemental.
  9. Trese Friday - 23 / 11 / 2012 Reply
    If what you say is true "she and I are developing a good relationship" then the basis for any good relationship is common values and honesty. You are not necessarily being judgmental just because you mention something that you disagree with. There is a way in how you say thing that make it judgmental or rather constructive rather than destructive. Casually and tactfully mentioning the reasons why YOU feel speaking to the children that way would be counterproductive opens up the conversation for her to express herself and then you go from there. The both of you will mull over the conversation in your minds for days to come and she will either do something or do nothing. Next the both of you will decide who you spend your time with. Bottom line, as you acknowledged, we all need to work on some aspect of our personality. A true friend, however, is one we can open up to about the challenges in our life and hopefully will always be a source of encouragement.
  10. Kim Reni Sunday - 03 / 02 / 2013 Reply
    I truly believe the truth in love is the answer. God is very intentional in how He 'orchestrates' our lives ... He knows just exactly what our needs are! There is a reason why the two of you are developing a friendship ... perhaps it is because God wants to use you to help this new friend of yours to make some different choices about how she deals with her children and how she presents her thoughts of her husband in front of her children because sooner or later the children are going to begin to think of their father in ways that are based on her opinion of him which can cause problems along the way for everyone. Of course there is a way to say everything, but if your friendship was divinely orchestrated then it's up to God to give you the words (the right words) to say at the right time ... He is faithful and will perfect the things that concern you (Ps. 138:8). Pray & then trust Him ... He'll work it out!
  11. Joy Sunday - 03 / 02 / 2013 Reply
    I say run, run, run! It is apparent that you don't share the same value system. When it comes to your family, I believe that shared values with friends is important. I need to model that behavior (choosing appropriate company) for my children.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Is it really “Kids These Days” or Have Kids Always Been This Out of Control? | Black and Married With Kids.com - A Positive Image of Marriage and Family - January 23, 2013

    [...] and nobody let him in. It’s winter, so it’s definitely cold outside. However, before he left, the mother said something to the extent of, “When you come home past curfew, don’t even bother knocking on the [...]

Add a comment

Free eBook:

Welcome to BMWK!

Our Latest Film: Still Standing




Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad
Ad

Facebook Fan Page